The sword needs to have a regular handle and blade for me to think of it as an actual sword. (I recommend the human campaign screen sword skins).
It has regular handle and the blade is meant for ritual piercing, not slashing.
I agree, the sword looks really cartoonish and silly, almost like it made of paper.
You should make a better sword, or remove it altogether and use something else to impale them with.
Regards,
Jake
Well the jeweld swords and daggers are made to look cool. My sword looks cool and is designed for ritual.
Also, imo - not realy creative model, cuz already was two of such models uploaded there on hive. Mostly it's far from something intresting. Try understand concept:
Some sword comes from nowhere and smashes heroe's head. Also - blue effect sucks, try make something more expressive.
Anyway, currently imo - stupid model. And yeah, no offense for sure.
I already made two similar models, that is true. I bet you have not tested it in game according to how I told you. This is the concept:
Unit gets levitated in the air and is rendered helpless, then giant sword conjures above it, slams down into the target and pins it to the ground.
I consider it to be cool.
Well, to be quite honest. A guillotine would probably make it more.. execution-like.
Well, to be honest, guillotine does not fit the concept. And it is too cliché.
Nice idea but the sword could use a little more detail.
Others complain it has too much detail
This made me lol.
Let me think, you're all good, walkin' on the streets, smokin' a cigarette and OMGWTF LOL! A SWORD BREAKS YOU IN TWO.
._.
That is NOT what comment thread is for.
Overall I am quite dissapointed. I clearly stated how you should have test this. i think some users have this urge to commet on anything that is posted. If you want to comment on something then please test it thoroughly, check for mistakes and post constructive criticism.
@PeeKay: I do not see what your problem is. I should really report your post. You trash my model, without apparent reason and expect me not to be offended. First of all you should respect me for my work, second you need to learn how to comment. All users here did not post anything else but how they do not like the idea. Well I love the idea of a giant sword pinning down on helpless target. If I trashed every model I did not like I would have 800 posts. The only fair users here were Jake and Yayoi who actually gave constructive criticism.