Moderator
M
Moderator
14:15, 21st Mar 2009 by bounty hunter2:
I see an improvement from the previous version, now here is my short review:
I have played quite some Helms Deep maps, and I must say this one does differ itself. The terrain was done greatly, really catching an epic feeling, that Helms Deep consists of. On some places there a bit too much rocks, but overall well done. Now, what I didn't like was the camera system. You shouldn't use dialogs for that, rather type in. And when I do switch the camera, an pan over one second is better then an immidiate pan. The idea isn't original, it was seen a lot of times before. The spells could require some more work, they should be triggered and done better. Anyway, this concludes my short review, Approved with a 3/5 (Useful) rating. Good job in making this map, polish it as much as possible, it would be a shame if I don't approve, and it allready has one T-Up for approval from a mini mod.
I see an improvement from the previous version, now here is my short review:
I have played quite some Helms Deep maps, and I must say this one does differ itself. The terrain was done greatly, really catching an epic feeling, that Helms Deep consists of. On some places there a bit too much rocks, but overall well done. Now, what I didn't like was the camera system. You shouldn't use dialogs for that, rather type in. And when I do switch the camera, an pan over one second is better then an immidiate pan. The idea isn't original, it was seen a lot of times before. The spells could require some more work, they should be triggered and done better. Anyway, this concludes my short review, Approved with a 3/5 (Useful) rating. Good job in making this map, polish it as much as possible, it would be a shame if I don't approve, and it allready has one T-Up for approval from a mini mod.